by Srinivas
Mirle, AID-Cincinnati, Jan 9, 2005
Dalits comprise about 17% of
India's population and continue to struggle to be included in mainstream
India. They have been marginalized in
India for ages and, surprisingly, they are not faring better even in the
aftermath of the tragic tsunami disaster.
This was evident from field visits that I made today with Ms. Shabnam
Hashmi of ANHAD to the tsunami-affected areas of Velankany, Nagapattinam and
Kesavanpalem in Tamil Nadu. Ms. Shruti
Parthasarathy, a volunteer from Bangalore who is working with AID on
coordinating relief activities in the village of Kuttiyandyur, has also
observed the Dalit denigration.
In the tsunami affected areas of
Tamil Nadu, there are about 8000 Dalit families who live in about 95
hamlets. About 30 hamlets were severely
affected and about 5000 huts have been washed away, according to Mr. Vincent
Manohar of the NCDHR, National Campaign for Dalit Human Rights.
Velankany is renowned for its
magnificent church and devotees come from far and wide. There was a significantly larger number of
devotees on the beach near the church the morning after Christmas when the
tsunami struck. About 2000 people
perished and of these dead, about 200 people were local residents.
In the Velankany area, there are
about 2000 Dalit families in about 60 villages and they were not provided any
shelters, according to Mr. Ayapillai, a Dalit activist. It was only after a HRFLD (Human Rights Forum
for Liberation of Dalits) leader, Mr. Ravi Chandran, was interviewed on TV
networks that the government machinery cooperated with NGO's in providing
shelters.
In Velankany and other areas, Dalit
municipal employees (so-called "scavengers") from several cities such as
Coimbatore and Tiruchirapalli were brought in to clear the dead bodies. Strangely, these workers were not provided
basic safety equipment such as gloves, masks or boots as they waded in the
slush or treaded amongst the mangled debris.
According to Mr. Manohar, personal protection equipment was provided to
other non-Dalit relief workers and even worn by officials who were largely
supervising the operations.
For a long time, the well-organized
fisherman group has apparently prevented Dalits from sea fishing. For the Dalits who eked out a living by
fishing, they had to fish inland where the catch was typically less. For the Dalits who worked on agriculture,
their future is uncertain as the soil has become saline and its fertility is
still being assessed. Even so, 90% of
the Dalits worked on land owned by others before the tsunami and do not know
what the future holds for them.
After the tsunami, that Dalits were
chased away by fisherfolk when Dalits tried to enter the relief camps,
according to Manohar. To add insult to
injury, the government machinery was also slower to react to Dalit needs. For example, drinking water supplies reached
non-Dalit areas but were tardy or negligent in reaching Dalit areas. According to Manohar, FIR's (First
Information Reports) to document missing people were not readily filed for
Dalits as they could then become eligible for the one lakh rupees issued for
each casualty by the government.
In Kuttiyandyur, Parthasarathy
found that the panchayat does not acknowledge that the Dalit hamlet of
Chinnamanikapanga is part of the main village.
Kuttiyandyur has a population of 1014 and 23 Dalit families live in
Chinnamanikapanga. The Chinnamanikapanga
families have received none of the immediate relief provisions provided by the
government. AID has worked with denizens
of both the village and the Dalit hamlet, while taking care to not alienate the
Panchayat and thereby lose its cooperation.
Parthasarathy and other volunteers have worked in Kuttiyandyur and are
now ready to move on as systems are in place and the village can manage on its
own. AID will continue to provide
much-needed supplies to Chinnamanikapanga.
It is important that the government and other relief agencies reach out
to Dalit hamlets such as Chinnamanikapanga, which have existed under difficult
conditions and are struggling to cope even more after the tsunami.
In the Nagapattinam/Karaikal area,
the tsunami was particularly devastating.
There have been thousands of deaths and estimates range as high as
14,000. Of these, 113 dead were believed
to be Dalits. 1914 Dalit homes were also
destroyed by the tsunami. The Dalits
were not able to stay in the relief camps that sheltered non-Dalits and the Dalit
relief camp had to be set up several kilometers away from their former dwellings.
In Keshavanpalem, 83 Dalit homes
close to the shore were washed away and nine Dalits died. According to Mr. Karuappan, a retired IAS
officer who is very active with Dalit causes through organizations such as
NCDHR and HRFLD, the Dalits have no shelters.
They staged a peaceful dharna (protest) in front of the local officials
who promised action in an hour. More
than two days have since passed and the shelters remain an empty promise. The Dalits occupy the sites of their
destroyed homes during the day and then go wherever they can, possibly the
homes of their relatives, for the night.
The tsunami has been a colossal
disaster and has affected people from many nations and many walks of life. Just as other communities have suffered, the
Dalits have also borne tragic losses. It
is sad that age-old discriminatory practices prevail even in this crisis
situation and the tsunami tragedy has been made more difficult to bear for the
long-suffering Dalits. |